Home
 
 
04 May 2008 @ 11:16 pm
[Fanfiction] "Kind Words"  
Fandom: Harry Potter
Title: Kind Words
Rating: PG-13
Summary: [info]lgbtfest prompt #376: Harry Potter: Albus Dumbledore. A young LGBT or questioning student (era and character of your choice) comes to the headmaster seeking advice, not knowing that Dumbledore himself is gay.
Characters/Pairing: Regulus, Dumbledore, implied Grindelwald/Dumbledore
Disclaimer: No, it's not mine.
Warnings: Adult language. Intolerance. Vaguely upsetting content. Angst.
Notes: I wrote this today. In basically two hours. And it's awful. And barely fits the prompt. But blame my [info]blind_go fic, which ate my brain. And had the same exact due date. And sucks anyway.



Kind Words


Regulus Black looked up from his book and sensed trouble. Several of his housemates had rushed into the common room, flushed and panting. One of them – a lanky seventh year with a face like a Grindylow’s – flexed his long fingers and occasionally prodded his bleeding, swollen lip. Standing next to him was one of the Slytherin Beaters, a boy named Eligius Trimble. Trimble had his arms folded defensively across his wide chest and was searching the room with wild eyes, seeking –


“You!” Regulus frowned. “Black, get over here.”


With a sigh, the fourth-year complied. Trimble wasn’t someone whose bad side he wanted to be on. The Beater was huge and mean, with all the personal charm of a Hungarian Horntail.


“You know, Black, your brother’s got some fucking nerve,” Trimble began. The tips of his ears were burning red, while his mouth trembled with fury. Regulus, barely noticing, just thought, Of course. Sirius was officially no longer a part of the family, having been quite soundly and effectively disinherited within minutes of his final departure, but the Slytherins had never forgiven Regulus for being Sirius’s brother – even if it was against his will.


Whatever Sirius had done this time, Regulus didn’t want to know. He never wanted to know, in fact, but his classmates always told him. Today they recounted the afternoon’s adventures in almost certainly incorrect detail (the bit about Sirius running away “like a fucking pansy” was particularly suspect), and then proceeded to catalogue Sirius’s many faults again. Regulus kept his mouth shut; he didn’t want to hear it, but it would be better to let the other boys talk themselves to death, even if all he wanted to say was I am not my brother’s keeper. He never had been, even back when they still considered each other family.


Trimble’s voice was rising with his rage, his words practically shaking the bookcases and at least drawing the interest of the few students still in the common room. His rant ran in endless circles, and none of it added up. It didn’t have to. The Slytherins hated Sirius Black, and the reasons for doing so didn’t always have to be sound.


Suddenly, with a sharp grin, Crispin, the seventh year with the split lip, said, “He’s a faggot, you know.” Someone laughed – a girl Regulus’s age – but everyone else just kept listening. It wasn’t the first time Regulus had heard Sirius called a faggot, or a queer, or a nancy boy, or – well. It wasn’t the first time, and it wasn’t something Regulus hadn’t considered himself. But no one had ever said it like it was indisputable fact, until now.


“Think about it,” Crispin continued. He didn’t have to raise his voice the way Trimble did; his words were soft, but everyone sat rapt. “Funny how he’s always with Potter, isn’t it? And if not Potter, then that Remus Lupin, or Peter Pettigrew.” Everyone made a face, disgust pulling their mouths into ugly grimaces. “His favorite thing in the world is probably taking it up the arse.” His cold eyes turned to Regulus, who suddenly understood. This wasn’t about Sirius at all. “Isn’t it?”


All Regulus had to do was agree, and Crispin – who two days ago had noticed Regulus peeking in the showers, fourteen years old, curious and aroused by the sight of another man’s penis – would back off. He’d be allowed to return to his book, and for now the boy would drop the subject. Protecting Sirius was not a priority for him any more than protecting Regulus was a priority for Sirius. Better by far to protect himself.


He licked his lips and nodded. “Yes.” He met the boy’s gaze. “He’s a filthy queer.”


*


The staircase curled upwards, and Albus Dumbledore ascended it quickly. He was running late. A quarter of an hour ago Horace had told him he had a student waiting in his office, but then he’d been sidetracked by one thing or another – the least of which being Peeves, launching a full-scale assault of ripened fruit on the newly-hired arithmancy professor. Pleased to see Professor Vector take it all in stride, Albus remembered her infectious laughter.


Still smiling, he opened the door.


For no more than a moment, he mistook the boy waiting by the desk for Sirius Black. It would make more sense – Sirius was a regular visitor to the office, whereas Regulus had never before stepped inside it, to Albus’s knowledge. However, aside from the obvious shared traits, the boys did not look alike. Regulus had dark features and an aristocratic nose, and though he was not as striking as Sirius, he was a handsome young man. His eyes sat deep in his face, dark and thoughtful, and his cheeks were peppered with barely-there freckles. In time, perhaps, he would grow into his looks, but for the moment he resembled his father.


“Regulus,” greeted Albus, his eyebrows rising above his glasses. He slipped into the chair at his desk and gestured for Regulus to take a seat. Had he been standing the whole time? “I’m sorry I’m late.”


Regulus’s expression was guarded as he shook his head. “It’s fine.” The words were terse, and it was becoming more and more clear that it was taking all his nerve to be there. Albus would have to ease the boy into speaking up.


He said, “When I was your age, I had a professor that never made it to class on time. Even the students who ran tardy in all of the other classes made it in before him.” Albus chuckled at the memory, years and years and years old. “It was frustrating. I was there to learn, and I felt he was making it impossible. Eventually I began teaching myself the material when he wasn’t there, and understanding it, and years later it occurred to me that this was exactly what he’d been hoping for. The whole thing was a lesson. When I saw him again, I told him I had figured it out – and he just stared at me and said, ‘Albus, what in Merlin’s name are you talking about? I was late every day because I never could find my way around this blasted castle!’”


Across the desk, Regulus didn’t smile. It seemed he hadn’t even registered the story. He was picking at his fingernails, waiting to speak but not knowing what to say. Albus could see the hesitance in his twitching fingers. “Um,” he managed. “Er.”


“Yes?” prompted Albus kindly.


Shaking his head, Regulus said finally, “It’s nothing.”


“Ah, but it’s clearly something. Or you would not be here, would you?” Albus knew that Regulus Black, like his mother and his father, did not look kindly on his policies. He would help Regulus in any way he could, of course, but it would take something important for Regulus to seek that help.


A long silence followed, until Regulus said, “If there was something you fancied that you wished you didn’t – is there a way to make you stop?”


Albus’s eyes twinkled, and he waited. Regulus wasn’t done.


Regulus chewed on his lip for a while. Albus didn’t push him. At last, he said – asked because it was obvious he couldn’t bear to just state it – in a small voice, “What if I don't want to be gay?”


Oh, thought Albus, and the pieces slid into place. He remembered being this young, this achingly vulnerable and terribly confused. Locked-away memories of a hot summer and a good friend rose, unbidden, in his heart, and though Albus wanted to look down, away, anywhere but at Regulus’s seeking eyes, he held the boy’s gaze. He owed it to him.


“There’s nothing to fix, nothing to change. Regulus,” he told him, remembering that someone had told him the same thing once, had pressed tiny kisses to the shell of his ear and assured him with the same words he was saying now. “It won’t be easy, and there is no spell to change you, but make no mistake that there is nothing wrong with who you are. Be proud of it.”


Regulus looked away first. Then he stood slowly and muttered, “Thanks for nothing,” and as he fled, he slammed the door. Albus, watching, didn’t let himself think of curls of golden hair beneath his fingers.


*


When he returned to the common room, several of his housemates – Regulus noticed Trimble’s enormous frame among the group – were gathered in a corner, whispering furiously. Regulus was still seething from Dumbledore’s little speech. What did that fraud know about anything? Did he understand the way Crispin had looked at him, or the words the other boys had said about Sirius? Regulus didn’t need self-acceptance; what he needed was to be different, to avoid the accusation he’d soon be seeing in his classmates’ stares.


Suddenly he heard a voice at his ear. “Step away, Black. What’s going on here isn’t for queers.”


Regulus turned and saw Crispin looming beside him, a tall, terrifying presence. Swallowing, he looked up into the older boy’s eyes. “Then you’ll get no problems from me. I’m no queer.”


Crispin smiled. “Glad to hear it.” He pulled Regulus toward the others. “You ever hear of the Death Eaters?”

- - -




Feedback would be terrifying but appreciated, because I do realize this is awful.
 
 
→  : in bed
♥  : at least i finished!
♫  : the perishers - "pills"
 
 
( Post a new comment )
Cimorene: exterminate![info]minkhollow on May 5th, 2008 05:37 am (UTC)
Oh, Regulus. While this does not suit my particular character concept of him, I can see it happening - especially considering he'd likely get double the hell at home that he did from his classmates.
It is not awful; in fact, it's quite good. I like that Dumbledore tried to be helpful, even though it sorta blew up in his face.
carmine_ink: ten[info]carmine_ink on May 5th, 2008 10:30 pm (UTC)
Oh hi there, icon made of awesome! ;p

code name mr. president: Doctor Who: Master: Vote Saxon[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 02:52 am (UTC)
Haha. I have many views of Regulus -- it's what's so, uh, nice about him. (YAY for inventing characters almost from scratch!) :D And Dumbledore -- he tries, he fails, it's kind of his bag. XD

Thank you so much!
the mysterious, (often maniacal) masked measured![info]measuringlife on May 5th, 2008 05:45 am (UTC)
This doesn't suck at all, you! >P *pokes!* I think it's a fascinating look into them, and how Regulus may have acted/dealt with things. I really loved Dumbledore's memories esp.
code name mr. president: Hikago: Sai: Beautiful[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 02:54 am (UTC)
Aw, thanks. I'm really uncomfortable posting something I've barely even had the chance to read over (*cough*like my Blind Go fic*cough*). Especially since I love the original idea of this piece, if not exactly the execution. Yeah. Thank you. ♥
I am the prophet Chuck![info]solar_cat on May 5th, 2008 06:51 am (UTC)
Oh, that definitely is NOT awful. In fact, it's really good. I never really conceived of a character for Regulus at all, so I don't really have a concept of him, but I like the way you portrayed him - he felt very young. Wise to certain truths about the world and yet wholly ignorant of others. And I like your Dumbledore, too. It strikes me as very him, to help in the way he knows is best but that doesn't necessarily help with the immediate situation.

So yes. I liked it. ^^
code name mr. president: FSM: Sarah Marshall: Shock[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 02:56 am (UTC)
*blushes* Thank you. I've conceived of Regulus in a lot of different ways, including this one. The Dumbledore characterization was really tricky -- it's a bit bland in its current state, but what can you do? -- so I'm glad to know it worked at least on some level. ♥
I am the prophet Chuck![info]solar_cat on May 6th, 2008 03:03 am (UTC)
Well, he's hard to characterize, no matter how you look at it. "Enigmatic" is kind of his watchword. And then she threw the "gay, with massive unrequited love for guy who was also greatest enemy", which is a massive 0_o to whatever we thought he was like all along. I mean, internally and all. So... yeah. I think you did a pretty good job with him. ^^
guad: rainbowguard[info]guad on May 5th, 2008 09:37 am (UTC)
I liked this story, and it totally makes sense to me.
code name mr. president: Harry Potter: Text: Dead Gay Headmaster[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 02:57 am (UTC)
Thank you. ♥
elsane[info]elsane on May 5th, 2008 12:49 pm (UTC)
Enjoyed! -- especially Dumbledore's anecdote, and how it goes over like a lead balloon. Like minkhollow, I tend to have a different idea of Regulus in my head, but this is all too plausible, poor boy.
code name mr. president: Harry Potter: Sirius + Remus + Harry[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 02:59 am (UTC)
I've got a lot of different ideas about Regulus -- this is just one. He's such a fun character to play with because we've really just got the bare bones of his identity to go off of. :D It's great.

Thank you. I'm glad you liked this, especially the anecdote which, as I was writing it, kind of made go WTF?
Student/Intern/"Sunshine": Heath Ledger[info]cellshader on May 5th, 2008 04:38 pm (UTC)
great work!
this is really great. really. *swats you with rolled up Heroes magazine*
seriously, you worry too much, and OMG you got regulas down...or what i assume regulas would have been like.
i especially loved the way you pull that haunted ending out, mention of deatheaters and all that.
and i liked your interpretation of how regulas and sirius's relationship worked --his "not his keeper" reaction and all that.

on the whole, really good work. you are win ^^ *reassuring hugs*
code name mr. president: Veronica Mars: Veronica + Logan: Love[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 03:00 am (UTC)
Thank you. I love writing the Sirius-Regulus relationship. It's so complex and fascinating in my head. Throw some gay into it (not incestuously!), and I'm in the place we call Happy Land. :D
Word with a sideways glance: Never trust those wise old wizards[info]rymenhild on May 5th, 2008 06:28 pm (UTC)
I love your Regulus. Your reading makes sense of everything we see him doing in canon. Also, Albus Dumbledore, failing to support Regulus despite the best of intentions and the most personal of experience, works perfectly. Thanks for writing.
code name mr. president: Harry Potter: Sirius + Remus + Harry[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 03:02 am (UTC)
Thank you. ♥ I'm happy to hear you appreciated what I was trying to do with Dumbledore. Because of the quick writing and difficulty with characterization, it didn't quite come across as clear as I'd hoped, but yay you got the point! ♥ Thanks. :D
darkandshiny[info]darkandshiny on May 5th, 2008 10:17 pm (UTC)
Like your Dumbledore, he's not always as perfect as some people (Even Harry in the first few books) make him out to be.
I never really had an impression of Regulus. All we had a a throw away line from Sirius Black, but you've eally put believable flesh to the bones. Well done!
code name mr. president: Torchwood: Ianto: Alone[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 03:03 am (UTC)
Thank you. Characterizing Dumbledore is difficult -- I've never really tried before, so this was really a challenge. And Regulus is fun to put together because he's so bare-bones to us. ♥
carmine_ink: qaf kiss[info]carmine_ink on May 5th, 2008 10:28 pm (UTC)
*smacks you* This is not awful at all. I actually squeed when I saw this in my flist, trufax.

I suppose it helps that I have a humongous weak spot for Regulus to begin with, but I really enjoyed this, Molly. I love how vulnerable your Regulus is, and I think the ending is brilliant and just gets me right in the gut. I've always thought of Regulus to be terribly concious of what people thought of him, and I think that interpretation works great in this context. Poor thing. :/
code name mr. president: Misc: Audrey + Me: Squee[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 03:05 am (UTC)
Aw, thank you. Really. Thank you. ♥ I get really uncomfortable about posting something I've spent only a couple hours writing, have barely proofread, and haven't had a single soul even glance at. O__O But this feedback is so lovely and makes me feel so much better, so, yeah, thank you! ♥ Regulus is a really fun character to write, because we really just have a vague outline of who he is. There's so much room for interpretation. But what we do know is really fascinating and compelling.

Thank you again! ♥
carmine_ink: cocoa blood[info]carmine_ink on May 7th, 2008 03:25 am (UTC)
My pleasure. ♥ Also, did you know you've been recced at [info]accio_rs_fics ?

http://community.livejournal.com/accio_rs_fics/405186.html

Just thought I'd let you know as it always makes me happy to stumble upon a rec for something I've written, so...
Master of Slanted Edges[info]slanted_edges on May 6th, 2008 02:20 am (UTC)
. . . *snort* "Regulas", huh? Keehee!

Anyway, I thought this was quite well written. You can tell that it wasn't something that was picked to peices -- it was just written to be written, and it works like that. It's got a looseness and fluidity like that.

For some reason, though, when I first read this this morning, the beginning bugged me. I dunno -- it just didn't pull me in. Like . . . the first sentence reminds me more of a summary of something than an actual something. Once I got past the first paragraph, though, this story held my complete attention.

Also, I like how to-the-point this story was. It didn't dwadle around needlessly -- you knew what needed to be said and that's what you said. It certainly created the right sort of mood for this story, and I like that you still made Regulus kind of a jerk. A jerk backed into a corner, because that certainly seems to be what he was in canon.

At first, when Dumbledore started telling that story, I was like, "Woah, that was sudden!" Like he just opened up to some complete stranger. But then I remembered who Dumbledore was and I thought, "Hey, you know, that'd actually be a good way to make a (non-pricky) student relax." So, yeah -- thumbs up!

Oh! Typo in here: "Regulus’s expression was guarded as he shook his head. 'It’s fine.' The words were terse, and it becoming more and more clear that it was taking all his nerve to be there. Albus would have to ease the boy into speaking up."

Should be: ". . . it was becoming more and more clear . . ." Yeah?

So. This was totally super special awesome in America!
code name mr. president: Haruhi Suzumiya: Kyon: Facepalm[info]aestheticized on May 6th, 2008 03:15 am (UTC)
*snorts* Oh, Katie. I love her, but she misspells/mispronounces many characters names. Often. :/

Thank you, darling, that's just lovely! You know I love when you give feedback, so don't be intimidated or feel like you always need to write this much. It's cool to just say "Awesome" or "This sucked, Molly, so just give up and go home" or "I have no particular feelings about this but just wanted to remind you that we are IN AMERICA!" Just to remind you. :D

But thank you for this feedback. What bothers me about the firstish paragraph, upon rereading, is mostly that the sentences are all about the same length. *headdesk* That's another pet peeve of mine.

REGULUS IS A JERK! I mean, I love him to pieces, but he's not a good guy. He was a Death Eater, for God's my sake. Other characters who are jerks: Sirius, Snape, Remus, James, Dumbledore, HARRY. The book is pretty much full of 'em. That's why they're interesting. *nods* *glares sharply at fic writers*

The story Dumbledore tells was kind of WTF? to me as I was writing it, but I just sort of went with it. I just sort of went with everything -- except my urge to write some Crispin/Regulus noncon. *headdesk*

Typo fixed! ♥

Even if it wasn't super special awesome in America, it wouldn't matter. Screw the rules, I have money!
a crazy random happenstance[info]secondsilk on May 8th, 2008 12:28 pm (UTC)
Fic: Kind Words
I love this sort of turning point type conversation for Regulus, and with the implications of Albus's past. Particularly his passing on the advice that had, ultimately, lead him to such difficulties. And Albus's anecdote about his Professor. Fabulous!
code name mr. president: Heroes: Nathan: Hair[info]aestheticized on May 10th, 2008 04:34 am (UTC)
Re: Fic: Kind Words
Thank you so much. ♥
rose[info]rose71 on May 16th, 2008 01:53 am (UTC)
I really enjoyed this! I like how your Regulus is dealing with such a complicated set of social pressures--not only homophobia, but the need to distinguish himself from Sirius. A dark version of Regulus, but it works here, and fits well with the not exactly great decisions he makes in canon.

And much love for the Dumbledore anecdote!
code name mr. president: Doctor Who: Master: Vote Saxon[info]aestheticized on June 3rd, 2008 01:03 am (UTC)
Thank you! :D I'm really fascinated by Regulus and Sirius's relationship, especially from Regulus's perspective, so I'm glad you picked up on that! Thanks. ♥
st_aurafina: Harry Fly![info]st_aurafina on May 30th, 2008 06:47 am (UTC)
Oh, Regulus! No! This is so sad - he's so young and desperate to fit in.
code name mr. president: Harry Potter: Sirius + Remus + Harry[info]aestheticized on June 3rd, 2008 01:04 am (UTC)
Regulus is, to me, a really interesting but tragic character. And it always surprises me to think of how young he really was when everything happened. D: Thanks for the feedback. ♥
i feel real weird for you: HP - Canon is love[info]mondayagain on June 23rd, 2008 06:06 am (UTC)
Oh, this is fantastic, and what's more, makes everything make SENSE. Poor, poor Regulus. Because you know he needed to belong, needed to be the same, and that dark side just called... salkfdj98jsosjk;lsdajf
code name mr. president: Harry Potter: Text: Dead Gay Headmaster[info]aestheticized on June 23rd, 2008 10:01 pm (UTC)
Aw, thanks. ♥ I think Regulus is a really fascinating character, so I like exploring his motivations. Especially when I think about how young he really was wen everything went down.